Government U-turn on promise to scrap ‘cattle truck’ trains

After promising train passengers in the North of England a ‘world-class rail network’, earlier this month, the government has U-turned on its promise to scrap the highly unpopular Pacer trains – also known as ‘cattle trucks’ – admitting that they may be now be ‘modernised’ and used for another 10 years.

I have previously complained in Parliament about constituents being treated like ‘sardines in a can’ on Northern Rail trains. It is an appalling U-turn from the government who have only just promised to provide the north with a ‘world-class rail network’ and a stinging embarrassment for George Osbourne who has claimed his vision for the north is that it should be ‘a powerhouse of the economy’!

I’m not sure how 30 year old ‘cattle trucks’ trundling up and down northern railways fits with the Chancellor’s vision of an economic powerhouse!

Commuters will be left incredulous by yet another example of broken promises and incompetence from this government illustrating a contemptuous attitude to the north.

I have previously said in my response to the TransPennine Express and Northern Rail Franchises’ consultation that investing in better quality and more railway carriages is imperative in order to meet growing demand.

There is evidence of the number of carriages being reduced recently, making commuting periods in particular very cramped, with passengers often forced to stand. This must be addressed.

Better rolling stock would encourage more people to use the network but, from speaking to constituents, they say they know they’ll have to stand on certain services so do not use them.

Greenfield station is a very well-used station and passenger numbers are increasing. The last figures available from 2012 to 2013 show the total number of passengers using the station was 331,068 compared with 306,426 in the previous year.

This, however, is a huge increase from 2004 to 2005 when user numbers were 161,558. It is vital that this growth continues, so that local residents are able to travel to and from work in Manchester, Leeds and other centres, as well as take advantage of leisure and cultural opportunities, without being dependent on their cars.

Skip to content